contain information about the electrical activity that produced them. The Argument from Religion "A major source of dualistic convictions is the religious belief many of us bring to these issues. If one can conceive of a possible world in which you have a mind without a body then mind and body are not identical. Looking in the mirror, he sees two empty sockets where his eyes should. "It is not entirely clear that such phenomena, even if real, must forever escape a purely physical explanation." high School Proposal The materialist can already suggest a possible mechanism for telepathy, for example. Maybe we just arent creative enough or intelligent enough to conceive of how it is possible. This proposition is metaphysically impossible because we cannot coherently describe any possible world in which such a thing obtains. The Argument from Introspection "A more universal consideration is the argument from introspection.
Dualism Arguments: Pros Cons, schoolWorkHelper
The materialist point of view is also easier to prove because there is no doubt that physical matter exists, while nonphysical matter is currently a hypothesis. 2 In this connection consider the proposition, A man survived a headlong fall from the top of the Empire State Building. This assumption is suspect because we already know that our other forms of observation - sight, hearing, touch, and so on - do no such thing. . If you can conceive of a possible world in which you have water without H2O, or H2O without water, then, sensu stricto, water and H2O are not identical but different substances. Is it that bad? A Related Principle of Identity, let us now use this distinction to articulate a principle of identity: A is identical to B if and only if it is metaphysically impossible for A to exist apart from B; that is, only if we cannot conceive. Applying this Principle of Identity to the Mind and Body. But conceivability of separateness does entail metaphysical nonidenticalitywhich simple precept does all the work of the argument.